Hallmark Mysteries & More
The podcast Sleuthers can’t stop talking about.
If you love Hallmark’s cozy whodunnits, sharp sleuths, and slow-burn romances, you’ve found your new favorite podcast. Hallmark Mysteries and More is the only podcast dedicated entirely to Hallmark’s beloved mystery movies and series, including fan-favorites like Mystery 101, Aurora Teagarden, Curious Caterer, The Cases of Mystery Lane, Signed, Sealed, Delivered, and beyond.
Hosted by real-life mystery buffs Andrea and Eric, each episode delivers smart, funny, and passionate deep dives into new releases and classic Hallmark mysteries. Expect honest reviews, character breakdowns, fan theories, behind-the-scenes trivia, and the kind of banter that feels like you’re sleuthing with friends.
🎥 Plus, we bring you exclusive interviews with Hallmark stars, directors, writers, and producers, giving fans rare access to the creative minds behind the mysteries.
Whether you’re a longtime Sleuther or brand-new to the genre, Hallmark Mysteries and More is your weekly escape into the warm, suspenseful world of Hallmark mysteries.
🕵️♀️ New episodes every week. Available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube.
📱 Follow us on Instagram & TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
🎧 Subscribe now and join thousands of mystery fans who never miss a clue.
Note: This podcast is fan-created and is not affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or Hallmark Media.
Episodes
240 episodes
How Good Was Hallmark's First Week of December? We Are Split!
We finally found a masterpiece with 12 Dates Till Christmas, but the rest of the week had us divided! 🎄 This week, Eric and Andrea review the latest holiday lineup, and while we both fell in love with the charm of ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 105
•
36:26
.png)
Lauren Cochrane - Life of a Hallmark Character Actor
What is it really like to be a "Character Actor" in the massive Hallmark movie universe? In this episode, we sit down with the hilarious and talented Lauren Cochrane (The Christmas Club, A Family Thanksgiving) to pull back the...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 104
•
45:36
.png)
Why Jessy Schram Loves Hallmark Movies (Plus Scoop on Her "Pretty Woman" Dress!)
I’m sitting down with the delightful Jessy Schram (Chicago Med, Falling Skies) to talk about her incredible career, from her early days starring in the Jane Doe mystery series to becoming a Hallmark Channel favorite! ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 103
•
23:28
.png)
Reviewing Hallmark's Thanksgiving Week's Movies
Thanksgiving brought Hallmark’s heavy hitters… but did they actually deliver?Eric and Andrea break down every single movie and special that aired over the long holiday weekend — from We Met in December to A C...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 102
•
49:05
.png)
Mistletoe Murders: Twas the Fight Before Christmas Review
Eric and Andrea dive into the final mystery of Mistletoe Murders: Twas the Fight Before Christmas. Eric has been loving Season 2 but Andrea has been lukewarm, still preferring Season 1. But did this mystery change all that?Plus they revi...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 101
•
33:13
.png)
Autumn Reeser and Niall Matter: We Met in December
Enjoy this exclusive, in-depth interview with Autumn Reeser and Niall Matter as they join me to talk about their new Hallmark Christmas movie We Met in December. Fans already know them as one of Hallmark’s strongest, most m...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 100
•
48:08
%208.11.57%E2%80%AFPM.png)
Mistletoe Murders Season 2 Ides of December Review
Andrea and Eric dive into the second installment of Mistletoe Murders' second season, Ides of December. As usual, Eric is all in and loving every minute, while Andrea seems to be a little more lukewarm to season two as a whole. This episode bri...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 99
•
37:58
.png)
Mistletoe Murders is Back! Cold War Review
Mistletoe Murders Season 2 is finally here, and after waiting 11 months, Eric and Andrea are absolutely ready to dive in. Well… after a quick detour through every Hallmark Christmas movie they missed last week because “schedules are ba...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 98
•
25:20
.png)
Chatting Mistletoe Murder with Sierra Marilyn Riley (Violet)
Mistletoe Murders Season 2 is finally here — and to celebrate, I’m joined by the one and only Sierra Marilyn Riley, who plays Violet! Sierra opens up about Season 2, her first on-screen kiss, her debut novel, and the wild coinci...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 97
•
45:58
.png)
Sarah Drew Dishes on Mistletoe Murders Season 2
Hallmark fans, this is the one you’ve been waiting for!Sarah Drew joins me to talk Mistletoe Murders Season 2, that unforgettable cliffhanger, the blue-dress moment everyone’s buzzing about, and what really happened behind the s...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 96
•
45:48
.png)
Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper Review
The Countdown to Christmas continues — and this week, Eric and Andrea unwrap Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper, starring Robert Buckley and Kimberly Sustad. Was this Buffalo-based holiday rom-com a cozy crowd-pleaser or another lukewarm snow...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 95
•
31:55
.png)
Top 5 Hallmark Movies of 2025 (and a couple you may want to skip)
Hallmark fans — grab your cocoa, because Eric, Andrea, and special guest Haley from Crown the Halls are counting down the Top 5 Hallmark Movies of 2025! From Villa Amore and Providence Falls to Haul Out the...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 94
•
57:46
.png)
Haunted Harmony Mysteries: Buried at C Review
After two years, we’re finally setting sail back to Ireland! In this episode, Eric and Andrea dive into Haunted Harmony Mysteries: Buried at Sea, starring Tamera Mowry-Housley as Gethsemane Brown — the music teacher who solves murders ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 93
•
21:55
.png)
A Haul Out the Halloween Spooky Review
Lacey Chabert and Wes Brown are back — and this time, Evergreen Lane is trading Christmas lights for cobwebs. In this episode, Eric and Andrea dive into Haul Out the Halloween, the delightfully spooky third installment of the Haul ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 92
•
22:01
.png)
A Conversation with Cindy Busby
Cindy Busby has starred in some of Hallmark’s most beloved movies — but her journey from Montreal to Hollywood is full of surprises, laughter, and heart. In this episode, Eric sits down with Cindy for a warm, funny, and refreshingly honest conv...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 91
•
1:03:57
.png)
Haunted Harmony's Marco Grazzini and Adam Fergus
This week, we're joined by Marco Grazzini and Adam Fergus, stars of the new Hallmark mystery Haunted Harmony Mysteries: Buried at C, premiering October 12th on Hallmark Mystery.If you're a fan of mysteries with a supernatural tw...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 90
•
49:41
.png)
Previewing 2025 Countdown to Christmas Movies
🔑 What You’ll HearOur Top 5 most-anticipated Hallmark Christmas movies for 2025The cast pairings we think will shine—Robert Buckley + Kimberley Sustad, Erin Krakow + Tyler Hynes, Autumn Reeser + Niall Matter, ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 89
•
55:52
Private Eyes Season 2 (Episodes 10-18)
What makes a cozy mystery click—and when does it fall flat? In this week’s episode, Eric and Andrea dive deep into Private Eyes Season 2, Episodes 10 through 18, unpacking the highs, lows, and surprising twists of the back half of the ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 88
•
44:03
Mystery Island: House Rules Review
What happens when Hallmark Mysteries takes its most divisive franchise back to the island? In this episode, Eric and Andrea dive into Mystery Island: House Rules, the latest installment in the cozy yet controversial series. From the su...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 87
•
26:57
Shakespeare & Hathaway Season 1 Review
Step into Stratford-upon-Avon with us as we review Shakespeare & Hathaway: Private Investigators (Season 1), now streaming on Hallmark Plus. Eric and Andrea dive deep into this quirky British cozy mystery series, unpacking the stan...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 86
•
42:38
.png)
A Complete Review of Thursday Murder Club (Netflix)
Netflix’s Thursday Murder Club takes Richard Osman’s bestselling cozy mystery from page to screen—but does it capture the book’s charm? In this episode, Eric and Andrea break down the performances, pacing, and production values of this...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 85
•
34:59
.png)
Private Eyes Season 2 Review (Ep 1-9) Shade and Angie are Back.
Private Eyes is back for Season 2—and Eric dives into the first nine episodes to see if Shade and Angie’s sleuthing still delivers that cozy mystery charm Hallmark fans love. From surprising guest stars (yes, William Shatner!) to standout story...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 84
•
37:45
.png)
A Conversation with Tommy Fields: Hallmark Movie Composer
What do Hallmark Movies sound like without the music? 🎶 In this episode, Eric sits down with Tommy Fields, the composer behind fan favorites like A Biltmore Christmas, Holiday Spectacular, and Savoring Paris. F...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 83
•
47:10
A Conversation with Siobhan Devine: Providence Falls Director
What happens when a Hallmark Channel favorite blends timeless romance, rich visuals, and a touch of cozy mystery charm? In this episode, Eric sits down with Siobhan Devine, director of Providence Falls, to talk about the behind-...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 82
•
14:53
.png)
Mystery Island: Play for Keeps Review
What happens when a Hallmark mystery heads to a remote island with a group of rich strangers, a locked-room setup, and a murder to solve? You’d think perfection. But in this episode of Hallmark Mysteries and More, Eric breaks down why ...
•
Season 3
•
Episode 81
•
11:23
